We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly. We support the following browsers:
Windows:
Internet Explorer,
Mozilla Firefox.
Mac:
Safari.
- Free Newsletter
-
Interested in New York City?
Explore the world! TripAdvisor has reviews and information on over 400,000 locations, including:
Explore other New York City resources:
Hotel class
356 West 58th Street, New York City, NY 10018
What travelers say about Hudson Hotel
-
Central park(111)
-
Rooms are small(62)
-
Great location(51)
-
Times Square(33)
-
Library Bar(26)
-
Sky terrace(25)
-
Friendly and helpful(25)
-
Very nice(25)
-
Front desk staff(21)
-
Public area(19)
Reviews you can trust
sarahchea...
Manchester
1 review
Reviewed May 31, 2011
- NEW
I planned our trip as a suprise for my fiance for his birthday (and joint engagment present). I have always wanted to stay at The Hudson, from seeing The Sanderson in London, another of Ian Schrager's hotels.
Once booked, I checked the reviews on here and was a little nervous about all the negative comments about room sizes and as...
more
Was this review helpful? Yes
Problem with this review?
RiverEddy
Albany, New York
2 reviews
Reviewed May 31, 2011
- NEW
I read a few reviews saying the rooms were small and that people had other issues, but I had a positive experience overall. I booked the room through priceline (naming my price of $190 a night, which worked out to about $220 after all taxes and fees and for memorial day weekend, I thought that was a pretty good price)....
more
Was this review helpful? Yes
Problem with this review?
ViniciusC...
Boston, Massachusetts
1 review
Reviewed May 31, 2011
- NEW
I had the misfortune to stay at the Hudson. At first, i was impressed with how beautiful/trendy it is, amazed with the friendly staff and i didn't even mind to wait in a long line to check in.
I knew in advance that rooms at the Hudson were tiny, which for me was acceptable. What was unnaceptable about that room...
more
Was this review helpful? Yes
Problem with this review?
PeDos
Zurich, Switzerland
1 review
Reviewed May 31, 2011
- NEW
The hotel is stylish and the location is great. And they life of the fact that this is NY and they do not depend on returning customers. Otherwise clearly the would improve their service.
Our rooms were not ready at 4 pm for check in. We got asked to refresh in the restrooms which were in a appalling state. And...
more
Was this review helpful? Yes
Problem with this review?
BizTrav30
London, United Kingdom
5 reviews
Reviewed May 30, 2011
- NEW
We decided to go to this hotel based on the review in the Taschen book (usually on the money) but this really is a case of all style, poorly executed, with no substance or service.
I am a huge fan of America but there are two things that annoy me - the universal claim to do food and hotels better...
more
Was this review helpful? Yes
Problem with this review?
pemigi
Zurich, Switzerland
2 reviews
Reviewed May 28, 2011
- NEW
The hotel is great. The design and style absolutely great. But....the service was the worst ever. We arrived late afternoon, rooms were not available. They asked us to wait for 45 minutes, we came back after 1.5 hrs - still no rooms. They sent us to refresh in the rest rooms which were in an appaling state. After that we...
more
Was this review helpful? Yes
Problem with this review?
Reviewed May 26, 2011
- NEW
1 person found this review helpful
Whilst I like boutique hotels, this one goes too far. As many others have said it's dark. Very very dark. Is this trendy or just hiding dirt? I upgraded to a suite which spared me the micro room, but it still wasn't generous - I would estimate 350sq ft, and there still wasn't enough room to walk around the bed...
more
Was this review helpful? Yes
Problem with this review?
zaheergb
Cape Town, South Africa
11 reviews
Reviewed May 26, 2011
- NEW
1 person found this review helpful
The rooms are tiny, but that's true of all New York hotels (and apartments). The staff are great and the hotel is really interesting. The design is beautiful and there is a great buzz in the lobby. The bar is great and so is the restaurant. I normally prefer getting out of the hotel i am staying in, but this...
more
Was this review helpful? Yes
Problem with this review?
Scar66
New York City, New York
1 review
Reviewed May 25, 2011
- NEW
1 person found this review helpful
This establishment needs to decide what it wants to be; a hotel or a nightclub. The hotel plays extremely loud music in its central atrium, onto which a large number of rooms overlook , and whilst this may appeal to to some, the word is, if you want to sleep/be functional during the daylight hours of your trip then do...
more
Was this review helpful? Yes
Problem with this review?
BenRyderU...
UK
2 reviews
Reviewed May 25, 2011
- NEW
4 people found this review helpful
This hotel, is without doubt, the worst hotel that I have ever had the misfortune to stay in.
Yes, that's a harshng statement. But it is also a true one. If you get the chance to read the other reviews for this hotel you'll notice it is a common theme, so isn't just me who has had a bad...
more
Was this review helpful? Yes
Problem with this review?
Travelers Who Viewed This Property Also Viewed
-
Location: New York City, NY
-
Location: New York City, NY
-
Location: New York City, NY
Average price/night*
-
Write Your Own Hotel Review
-
Been to Hudson Hotel? Share your experiences!
Write a Review
Add Photos
Add Videos
Other TripAdvisor sites:
See all sites
Cruise Critic
The ultimate cruise resource: cruise reviews, deals, news and advice.
SeatGuru
The world's most comprehensive source for airline seats, airline info, & in-flight amenities.
Family Vacation Critic
The best family vacations start here.
| |